Herbal products will be banned from EU soon.

post-edit 2 comments
Thousands of kilometres away from their fractious border, India and China face a common threat. From May 1, a Brussels diktat known as the herbal directive, will effectively outlaw ayurvedic and Traditional Chinese Medicines (TCM) from the 27-member countries of the European Union.

The directive in question was adopted in 2004 but it granted a seven-year grace period to manufacturers of herbal medicines to register, a deadline that expires on April 30.
The spokesperson for the European Commission’s department for health and consumer protection insisted that far from “banning” ayurveda or TCM from the EU, the directive in fact sought to make it easier for manufacturers of herbal products to register and market their wares in Europe.

“Given the particular characteristics of traditional herbal products, notably their long tradition of use, the directive has introduced a lighter, simpler and less costly registration procedure for them,” the spokesperson said in a written statement.

On the ground

The reality on the ground appears different. Last month, representatives from India’s ministry of health met their relevant counterparts in the EC to discuss the ayurveda issue. A source in the Indian embassy in Brussels who was present at the meeting revealed the Indian side asked the Europeans a single, simple question: had even a single ayurvedic drug been registered under the new rules over the past seven years?

No answer was forthcoming. Alternative medicine advocacy groups like the UK-based Alliance for Natural Health (ANH) say not a single drug emanating from a non-European medicinal system has in fact been able to register under the directive, despite attempts to do so.

The EC’s response to a direct query from this reporter was simply to state that registration was a “national procedure” and no information was as yet available on whether any ayurvedic or TCM products had been registered.

The EC stressed that under the new directive, traditional herbal products were exempt from the safety and efficacy tests that apply to allopathic medicines and instead had to merely prove that they had been continuously used for the past 30 years, including at least 15 years within the EU.

But Robert Verkerk, the founder of ANH, points out that prior to 2004, the vast majority of traditional herbal medicines available in Europe were categorised as food supplements rather than medicines and, therefore, not subject to stringent pharmaceutical testing.

The Indian embassy source adds that although the Indian government’s AYUSH (ayurveda, yoga and naturopathy, unani, siddha and homoeopathy) department is assisting a few ayurveda companies to apply for registration, a major stumbling block has been providing the kind of documentation required by the EU to prove use within the region for 15 years. The fact that most non-European traditions of herbal medication involve multi-herb preparations, including herbs that European agencies are unfamiliar with, rather than single herbs is a complicating factor. Member-states moreover continue to require proof of “quality” for the herbal compounds in question. But the standards they impose, such as “stability and genotoxicity testing” are not suitable for non-Western, poly-herbal products, according to the ANH.

Verkerk explains that “stability” is a particularly bad criterion by which to judge ayurveda and TCM products, since they comprise multiple herbs that continuously interact with each other. “In a sense, these are more like food stuffs and vary depending on how old they are, when the herbs in question were picked, where they were grown and so on.”

Access rights

Even if manufacturers of ayurveda are somehow able to cobble all the required data, the cost of registration remains prohibitive. The ANA estimates it to be upwards of ¤250,000 per product. A figure that is unaffordable for the majority of ayurveda manufacturers, which are small and medium enterprises operating on a model involving the sale of a wide range of products in relatively small volumes.

The fact is that before the 2004 directive, many of the traditional medicinal products on the market were sold either illegally or, as ANH points out, as food supplements. The new herbal directive seeks to transform this situation, in addition to harmonising what were previously a host of contradictory regulations amongst the EU’s 27 countries. But promoters and consumers of herbal medications say that access to these products should be framed as a human right, rather than as a legal or trade issue. The ANH asserts there is scant proof of any harm to human heath from the use of ayurvedic or TCM products in Europe prior to 2004, so that making safety the reason for the directive is disingenuous.

Regardless of where one stands on this debate, the fact of the matter is that come May, ayurveda and TCM exports to Europe, which represent a significant business interest, will be seriously affected.

The Indian government is attempting to deflect this negative impact by negotiating a clause in the ongoing India-EU free trade agreement that would grant ayurveda a special exemption from the directive. 

News Courtesy: business standard
Image Courtesy: bikudo.com

Do you Like this story..?

Get Free Email Updates!

*Your email address will not be shared with anyone.

Follow us!

2 comments:

Siddha medicines, ayurvedic medicines, and TCMs are made from herbs. It is a well known fact.
While EU has to do a tremendous job in FOOD AND DRUGS IMPORTS, I am not sure that they know what to check in allopathic drugs and food and nutritive value products, and energy drinks and aerated drinks all of which contain unrestricted amounts of toxins, or chemicalswith side reactions. Europe will become another country for cancer deaths if first and foremost, the food and drugs from the West is not monitored. How to monitor?
What chemicals are ingredients?
Ingredients include many unwholesome, unhealthy chemicals for shelf life, flaking agents, colouring agents, etc
What processes are involved in making it?

01.I DO NOT SUPPORT AYURVEDA fully. Because processing methods have changed to commercial methods in Ayurveda. People add anything they want and do not feel responsible toward the patient as it is an intaken food/medicine by him.
Very basic questionable thing : In a recent testof honey brands available in Delhi, a leading consumer forum lab tested all the brands and came up ONLY WITH ONE BRAND of honey without allopathic antibiotic chemicals. Many honeybrands have ampicillin, tetramycin etc added knowingly thru bee from pollen from flowers/fertilisers/insecticides or unwittingly added to lengthen shelf life.
IS THERE A SINGLE BRAND OF HONEY IN INDIA WHICH IS RELIABLE?? in south?
CERC Ahmedabad conducted this test. You can subscribe and get the article in detail.
02. WHY AYURVEDIC COMPANIES ARE ADDING SUGAR,that too white sugar in many ayurvedic toothpastes, medicines etc? It is no where mentioned in ayurveda to add this white poison, because when Charaka and Dhanwanthri were all living, white sugar was unseen poison.IS THERE ANY COMPANY NO ADDING WHITE SUGAR IN AY DRUGS?
There may be a few siddha companies.
03.ALLOPATHY OR AYURVEDA OR TCM ?!! All those who are behind them are Humans liable to commit serious and severe Crimes in Food and Drugs.
In allopathy It is now leading and it has gone out of proportions. 1 out of every 8 women has br cancer in the US they say.
ALL BECOME COMMERCIAL AND HAVE HIGH EGO AND FORGET THEIR SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITIES AND SOCIAL CONSCIENCE. The Siddha man should never become like that, because he has a greater tradition.

You may visit my site:
www.sunflowerdance.com
AND ANOTHER EYE OPENING SITE ON ALLOPATHIC DRUG
INVASION OF THE WESTERN HEALTH!
www.naturalnews.com

D.PARAMESWARAN
sunflowerdancetrust for health
we regularly take classes on naturopathy,lifestyle, yoga and herbs.
WISHING ALL THE MEMBERS A GOOD HEALTHY LIFE!

February 20, 2011 at 6:30 PM comment-delete

Siddha medicines, ayurvedic medicines, and TCMs are made from herbs. It is a well known fact.
While EU has to do a tremendous job in FOOD AND DRUGS IMPORTS, I am not sure that they know what to check in allopathic drugs and food and nutritive value products, and energy drinks and aerated drinks all of which contain unrestricted amounts of toxins, or chemicalswith side reactions. Europe will become another country for cancer deaths if first and foremost, the food and drugs from the West is not monitored. How to monitor?
What chemicals are ingredients?
Ingredients include many unwholesome, unhealthy chemicals for shelf life, flaking agents, colouring agents, etc
What processes are involved in making it?

01.I DO NOT SUPPORT AYURVEDA fully. Because processing methods have changed to commercial methods in Ayurveda. People add anything they want and do not feel responsible toward the patient as it is an intaken food/medicine by him.
Very basic questionable thing : In a recent testof honey brands available in Delhi, a leading consumer forum lab tested all the brands and came up ONLY WITH ONE BRAND of honey without allopathic antibiotic chemicals. Many honeybrands have ampicillin, tetramycin etc added knowingly thru bee from pollen from flowers/fertilisers/insecticides or unwittingly added to lengthen shelf life.
IS THERE A SINGLE BRAND OF HONEY IN INDIA WHICH IS RELIABLE?? in south?
CERC Ahmedabad conducted this test. You can subscribe and get the article in detail.
02. WHY AYURVEDIC COMPANIES ARE ADDING SUGAR,that too white sugar in many ayurvedic toothpastes, medicines etc? It is no where mentioned in ayurveda to add this white poison, because when Charaka and Dhanwanthri were all living, white sugar was unseen poison.IS THERE ANY COMPANY NO ADDING WHITE SUGAR IN AY DRUGS?
There may be a few siddha companies.
03.ALLOPATHY OR AYURVEDA OR TCM ?!! All those who are behind them are Humans liable to commit serious and severe Crimes in Food and Drugs.
In allopathy It is now leading and it has gone out of proportions. 1 out of every 8 women has br cancer in the US they say.
ALL BECOME COMMERCIAL AND HAVE HIGH EGO AND FORGET THEIR SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITIES AND SOCIAL CONSCIENCE. The Siddha man should never become like that, because he has a greater tradition.

You may visit my site:
www.sunflowerdance.com
AND ANOTHER EYE OPENING SITE ON ALLOPATHIC DRUG
INVASION OF THE WESTERN HEALTH!
www.naturalnews.com

D.PARAMESWARAN
sunflowerdancetrust for health
we regularly take classes on naturopathy,lifestyle, yoga and herbs.
WISHING ALL THE MEMBERS A GOOD HEALTHY LIFE!

July 22, 2011 at 11:58 AM comment-delete
Post a Comment

Copyright 2011 SIDDHADREAMS